Case study interviews are a crucial stage in the hiring process, especially for roles in management consulting and other analytical professions. These interviews test your problem-solving abilities, analytical skills, and business acumen through real-world business scenarios. This comprehensive guide will break down the essential components of a case study interview, from understanding the format to formulating a conclusion, ensuring you are well-prepared to succeed.
What is a Case Study Interview and Why Are They Used?
A case study interview is a unique type of interview where candidates are given a business problem to solve. This format allows employers to see if candidates can translate their academic knowledge into practical solutions. Essentially, it's a test to see if you can do the job before you have it. Companies use this method to evaluate your problem-solving process, analytical skills, and ability to handle real-world business challenges under pressure.
During a case study interview, you'll be asked to solve a problem that would typically take a team months to address, all within a 30-40 minute timeframe. This high-pressure scenario is designed to test your ability to think on your feet and handle multiple tasks simultaneously. While this format is most commonly used in management consulting, it can also be found in various other industries.
Common Case Study Interview Formats
Understanding the two main types of case study interviews is essential: interviewer-led and candidate-led. Companies often use a blend of these formats, so being familiar with both is crucial.
Interviewer-Led Case Studies: In this format, the interviewer is highly involved throughout the process. They guide the candidate by asking specific questions and often interrupt to introduce new elements or mini-cases within the larger case. This requires candidates to be agile, organized, and quick-thinking.
Candidate-Led Case Studies: Here, the interviewer provides a vague problem statement and lets the candidate take the lead in solving it. The candidate must ask clarifying questions, structure their approach, and present their findings with minimal guidance. This format tests the candidate's ability to independently navigate complex problems and communicate their methodology effectively.
Key Skills Tested in Case Study Interviews
Employers use case study interviews to assess several critical skills:
Business Acumen: Understanding core business concepts such as profitability, market sizing, pricing, mergers and acquisitions, competitive analysis, and cost-benefit analysis is crucial. These are the foundations of most case study problems.
Soft Skills: Interpersonal skills, including confidence, humility, intelligence, and eloquence, are just as important as technical skills. Employers want to ensure that you can represent the company well in client-facing roles.
Analytical Skills: Your ability to quickly sift through data and synthesize it into a coherent conclusion is essential. Strategic thinking and problem-solving are at the heart of case study interviews.
Preparing for a Case Study Interview
Preparation is key to succeeding in a case study interview. Here are some steps to help you get ready:
Understand the Format: Familiarize yourself with both interviewer-led and candidate-led formats. Practice staying organized and thinking on your feet for the former, and leading the conversation and structuring your approach for the latter.
Practice Frameworks: Learn and practice common business frameworks such as profitability, the Four P's (Product, Price, Place, Promotion), market entry, and pricing frameworks. These will help you structure your analysis and present your findings clearly.
Develop Analytical Skills: Work on your mental math and data analysis skills. Practice breaking down problems into smaller components and systematically solving them.
Mock Interviews: Conduct mock case study interviews with friends, mentors, or through professional services. This will help you get comfortable with the format and receive feedback on your performance.
The Importance of Asking Clarifying Questions
One of the first steps in a case study interview is to ask clarifying questions. This is crucial because case study prompts are often intentionally vague. Asking questions helps you gather the necessary information to structure your analysis effectively. For example, if given a problem about a gas station's convenience store profitability, you might ask about the store layout, most profitable products, and customer demographics.
Asking thoughtful questions demonstrates your curiosity, attention to detail, and ability to identify key factors in a business problem. It also helps you avoid making assumptions that could lead to incorrect conclusions.
Creating a Framework
Creating a framework is an essential part of solving a case study. A framework helps you break down the problem into manageable components and ensures that your analysis is comprehensive and logical. Here's how to develop an effective framework:
Sketch It Out: Visualize the problem by sketching it out. This could be a tree diagram, flowchart, or any other visual aid that helps you structure your thoughts.
Make It MECE: Ensure your framework is Mutually Exclusive and Collectively Exhaustive (MECE). This means breaking down the problem into distinct, non-overlapping parts that cover all possible areas of analysis.
Practice Regularly: The more you practice creating and using frameworks, the more intuitive the process will become. Apply frameworks to everyday problems to hone your skills.
Developing a Conclusion
The conclusion of your case study interview is where you bring everything together and provide a clear, actionable recommendation. Follow this step-by-step approach to craft a compelling conclusion:
Repeat the Case: Summarize the problem briefly to frame your answer.
Answer Directly: Provide a direct answer to the main question without waffling.
Support with Evidence: Highlight three main pieces of evidence that support your conclusion.
Provide a Prescription: Outline the next steps or a procedure for implementing your recommendation. This shows that you are solution-oriented and can think beyond just identifying the problem.
Engaging Your Interviewer
Engaging your interviewer is critical in a case study interview. Here are some tips to help you make a positive impression:
First Impressions Matter: Make sure to greet your interviewer warmly, with a firm handshake and a confident demeanor.
Build Rapport: Use small talk to ease into the interview. This helps reduce tension and makes the interaction more comfortable.
Listen Well: Pay close attention to the interviewer's instructions and questions. Active listening is key to understanding the problem fully.
Create Conversation: Turn the interview into a discussion. Use the interviewer's name, ask for their input, and explain your thought process clearly.
Ask Questions: Engage the interviewer by asking relevant, insightful questions about the case. This shows your interest and analytical thinking.
Final Tips for Success
Practice Regularly: Consistent practice is essential. Use online resources, case study books, and mock interviews to refine your skills.
Stay Calm Under Pressure: Case study interviews are designed to be high-pressure. Stay calm, take your time to think, and approach the problem methodically.
Be Confident: Confidence is key. Believe in your abilities and communicate your ideas clearly and assertively.
By understanding the format, preparing thoroughly, and engaging effectively, you can excel in your case study interview and move one step closer to landing your dream job.
Example of common cases: Profitability
- Okay, tell me what you think of this. A travel agency you currently work for profits $3 million before taxes. For reference, they make 10% commission on all travel bookings. When you look at their peers, though, the industry average ranges from $5 million to $7 million profit. Why do you think they're making less than industry average? - Okay well, first things first. What are they actually making a commission on? What are they selling? - Sure, they sell hotel rooms. - Anything else? - No. - And what do their peers sell? - [Woman] Same thing. - Oh, okay. So that tells me the industry is pretty standard across the board. So it seems a little odd that there's such a discrepancy between this agency and the industry. You said the agency makes a 10% commission? Is that industry standard? - Yep. - Okay. Trying to understand the total value here. How many bookings did they have, and what was the average per booking? - They had 1 million bookings, and the average value was $120. - Okay, and how'd that compare to their competitors? - When compared to their competitors, they had more bookings, but the average value was smaller. - So based on these assumptions, that's $120 million. We break that down at a 10% commission. That comes out to $12 million. Break that down a little bit further, and that's about $12 in revenue per booking. Now we got to look at the costs. What are the fixed costs as compared to their competitors? - They're the same. - Okay, so we don't even have to take that into consideration for this example. What are the variable costs? - They are also industry standard at $9.00 - Okay, so we will take that into consideration because it's variable. That definitely helps us to get to that $3 million in profits. Huh, the only solution that it's really bringing me to, is, if that's industry standard, you can't just prompt people to buy more, then we end up with the same problem. What if we take a look at the average booking amount? How's that segmented? Do you know what the customer is? - Sure. When you look further into this, we can see that that $120 is made up of $66 spent by vacationers, and about 200 for business travelers. - That's $6.60 in profit. It's costing us $9, so these folks are actually costing us money. - Yeah, so what do you suggest then? - So in summation, the travel agency is having a problem with profitability, and with so many things being standard across the industry, we decide to look at the average booking amount. Once we segmented their customer base, we realized that vacationers are costing us money, whereas if we focus on business travelers, we can increase profitability exponentially. So the travel agency should focus more on business travelers. If they do, they can blow their competitors out of the water. - Great work. Let's move on to the next one.
Example of common cases: Sizing
- All right, here's your next case. Very simple. What is the market size for smartphones globally? - Okay. Well, a couple questions to determine the size. Are there any exceptions or limitations to that global number, or are we truly speaking everyone on Earth? - You're correct. We're talking about every person on Earth. - Okay. And what do we consider a smartphone? - Sure, any phone that has multiple uses besides just talking on the phone. - Perfect, so we're going to assume that any phone that you can text and talk on, at least, is a smartphone. - Yes. - Okay, and what's the timeframe? It's a year? - Over the current time period. - In that case, we'll consider it on a yearly basis. Great. And other question, are we determining the market size based on phones or on revenue? - Great question. Annual revenue of new sales. - Okay, great. Okay, so to determine this, we have to figure out the amount of smartphones being sold. And if we take into account an average cost of $500 per phone, then we'd multiply the amount of smartphones by $500. - Great, walk me through. - Okay. We would then want to segment into first-time buyers versus repeat buyers. Let's say there's seven billion people in the world. Seven billion people who has an average life expectancy of about 70-years-old. Seven billion by 70, that comes out to 100 million. So at any given point in time, there are 100 million people of any age. That's 100 million five-year-olds, 100 million 65-year-olds. - Sounds good. - Okay, but then there's the other side of the problem, which is going to be existing users. Let's say that's, it's not everybody in the world has the means to own a smartphone, right? So that's going to be about 40%, or 40 million people becoming new users. - [Female] Okay, sounds good. - So follow this line of thinking. That comes out to 40% of people using smartphones. 40% of seven billion comes out to three billion. Most phones have an average life expectancy of about five years, so that would be three billion divided by five. That comes out to 600 million. Then we add in that 40 million existing customers. And that brings us to 640 million. 640 million, multiply that by $500 per phone. And that gives us $300 billion. - So, what's your answer? - So, my answer is the global market size for smartphones is $300 billion. - Great work. Let's move on to the next one.
Example of common cases: Pricing
- Okay, here's what I need to solve for. It's 2015 and there's a new phone coming out. It has a lot of hype around it. From preliminary research, we found that 20% of buyers will pay up to $800, 40% will pay up to $600, and the rest will pay up to $400. How would you price this product at launch? - And there can only be one price at launch, right? - Yes. - And what's the company's main goal with the launch? Are they trying to maximize profits or just get the phone in more people's hands, create buzz? - Probably, profit. - Okay, what's the average competitor's phone? I know this phone's different, has different benefits, but what would a comparable phone cost? - Their competitors priced their similar phone at $500. - Okay, and is the company looking to maximize on any other income opportunities, let's say, accessories, data plans, or recurring charges? - No, for the purposes of this launch, they're solely focused on the hardware. - What's the cost of the phone? - $300. - [Interviewee] Is that fixed or variable? - Variable. - Are there any fixed costs? - [Interviewer] Nope. - Okay. All right, so let's go back to the original prompt. Company wants to maximize profits, right? In that case, I'm going to create a chart that will show each pricing option. Now, based on my calculations, we'd subtract the price of the phone and the cost of the phone. That'll give us total profit per phone. Add in the volume indicated based on people's willingness to actually buy, and that'll lead to the profit, which the company is trying to focus on. Taking all of that into consideration, I think the best pricing option is going to be $600. $600, willingness to buy is at 60%. That gives us $180 in profit, and that is going to be $80 more than any of these other pricing options. Also, just from a standing standpoint, we think about the fact that other companies are selling their phones at $500. If we're selling ours at $600, that's $100 premium. And with that, it makes this phone top of the industry. - Great, thanks for that explanation. Great work.
Example of common cases: New market
- All right, here's the next case for you. We have a US-based client that owns a fast casual healthy eatery. The company's main market has been in New York City, but they've seen a decline in profitability over the past couple of years. The company has plenty of capital to invest, and so they're looking into the following three cities to move into. San Francisco, Nashville, and Austin. Which one should they move into? - Okay. So you said there's been a decline in profitability. What's been the biggest cost change? - The real estate prices in New York City have doubled. - Okay, that will definitely eat into your margins. Okay, is there anything else? - Yes, it's been a lot harder to get fresh ingredients into the city due to increased regulations and logistical nightmares within the city. - Okay. And what is the market share for an eatery like this in New York? - Well, they've seen a decline over the past five years from five billion to four billion. - Okay, and do you know the market share in San Francisco, Nashville, and Austin? - Sure. It is San Francisco has five billion with a 10% growth projection, Nashville has two billion with 5% growth, and Austin comes in at three billion with 10% growth as well. - Okay, perfect, thank you. And do you have an understanding of the potential market share in these cities? Trying to understand the revenue potential over the next five years, so I can give a recommendation. - Yes, San Francisco has 5%, Nashville with 15%, and Austin with 10%. - Okay. So based on these numbers, and a little bit of quick math, I think Austin is the best bet, because Austin has an expected revenue of $300 million. The way that I came to that was I just took the market size, multiplied it by the growth rate, and then multiplied that by the market share. - Okay, so what's your final recommendation? - Austin. I think they should open their next place in Austin. It has the most growth potential. And from a quantitative state, I think that they'll get the highest revenue there. And if we just look at circumstantial evidence, San Francisco is going to have the same logistical and regulatory nightmares that New York City has. And Nashville isn't quite as big as Austin, so there's not as much room for growth. They should move to Austin. - Great work.
These were straightforward examples of case study interviews. For those looking to delve into more complex scenarios involving ambiguity and multiple viable solutions, we invite you to explore the materials below. Each case study is uniquely challenging and includes expert interpretations and clarifications from recruiters to help you navigate through different possible answers.
Comments